The likely nationalisation of British Steel presents an opportunity to reimagine one of the UK’s most carbon-intensive, but vital, industries. The substantial challenges — global competition, carbon intensity, shrinking market share — aren’t just constraints, they can be catalysts for our most creative thinking.
To get to new answers, I've started asking myself and our industry new questions.
From "what is" to "what if"
1. What if we thought generationally, not electorally?
Decision making based on electoral cycles is too short for multigenerational challenges.
Rather than chasing short-term gains, imagine:
— A Steel Futures Fund: A long-term investment vehicle akin to Norway's Government Pension Fund, which has successfully managed oil wealth for long-term national benefit, this could operate as a focused industrial transition vehicle. The public could invest directly through Industrial Sovereignty Bonds with guaranteed returns over 15-25 years, creating genuine public ownership of the transition process.
— A National Industrial Constitution: A framework protecting strategic industries from political swings, overseen by an Industrial Strategy Commission with statutory powers, similar to those used by the Committee on Climate Change.
Quote
Reimagining steel is not just about preserving an industry. With the right questions, it’s a chance to forge a bold, community-driven, low-carbon future at the heart of UK manufacturing.
2. What if we created innovation hubs beyond production?
What if we could pivot our industrial legacy into future-ready centres with Steel Innovation Districts.
Incorporating R&D labs, university partnerships and start-up incubators into former steel towns, the Advanced Manufacturing Research Centre (AMRC) in Sheffield provides a compelling template. Where coal miners once worked, forward-thinking engineers now develop aerospace components and pioneering techniques, attracting investment from Boeing, McLaren and Rolls-Royce while creating thousands of specialised jobs.
This approach challenges conventional thinking around former industrial sites. The AMRC demonstrates the circular economy at urban scale. A site that once provided raw materials now generates intellectual capital. Sheffield has extended this model with its BuildZero programme where Elliott Wood is an industry partner. The programme bridges academic research and industry application to accelerate the transition to net zero carbon in the built environment.
3. What if green steel became the default?
If we inspire ourselves with Sweden’s HYBRIT initiative, can we imagine:
— Hydrogen Steel Valleys in the UK’s North Sea regions: Powered by offshore wind they could generate green hydrogen at scale, creating a direct supply chain to decarbonised steel production. Co-locating hydrogen production with steel manufacturing would minimise transportation costs and maximise efficiency.
— Reformed energy pricing: Links electricity prices to gas, regardless of generation source. This market structure penalises energy-intensive industries and undermines the competitiveness of green steel production. A reformed pricing mechanism (like Sweden’s) that decouples renewable electricity from fossil fuel costs would create a stable foundation for investment in hydrogen infrastructure and electrified steelmaking.
— Captured waste heat: These Hydrogen Steel Valleys could become examples of industrial symbiosis where waste heat powers community heating systems, as successfully demonstrated in Stockholm Data Parks. Steel plants generate significant thermal energy that typically dissipates as waste. Capturing and distributing this through district heating networks creates additional value streams while reducing community energy costs.
4. What if steel was woven into community life?
What if we could redefine ownership and local benefit with:
— Community Steel Trusts: Steel facilities with local ownership stakes (workers, residents, investors). The Mondragon Corporation in Spain demonstrates how worker ownership can create resilient industrial enterprises that prioritise community wellbeing alongside commercial success. A percentage of profits could fund community development, skills training, and ecological restoration projects, creating a virtuous cycle where steel production directly enhances local prosperity and environmental health.
— Urban Mining & Upcycling Centres in communities: Steel's infinite recyclability represents an underutilised opportunity to create new value chains. Local steel recovery hubs could process everything from demolished buildings to end-of-life vehicles, creating specialised SMEs focused on material separation, processing and remanufacturing. These operations would not only create diverse employment opportunities but also develop valuable expertise in material science and circular economy practices.
— Abandoned steelworks become mixed-use districts combining light manufacturing, creative industries, and cultural spaces: The scale and character of steel infrastructure lends itself to imaginative adaptive reuse. Blast furnaces could become distinctive landmarks within new innovation districts. Vast production halls might house multiple smaller enterprises using advanced manufacturing techniques.
Reimagining steel is not just about preserving an industry. With the right questions, it’s a chance to forge a bold, community-driven, low-carbon future at the heart of UK manufacturing.
